Saturday, September 26, 2009

I raised my hand in class but I was cut off by the bell, so this is my contribution to the discussion:

The notion of whether the American Revolution was a social revolution or not is based on an individuals perspective. If the American Revolution was being compared to, lets say, the French or Haitian Revolution, then no, it was not much of a social revolution. The Haitian Revolution was a complete social revolution where the slaves managed to not only gain freedom but the power to govern themselves. The bourgeoisie in France took complete control of power from the aristocracy, compared to America, where there was no real shift of power from one class to another. On the other hand, if you compare America's revolution to a Middle Eastern Nation's social revolution, where there has not really been one, then yes, the American Revolution was a social revolution. This argument can be taken from many, many different angles all with legitimate explanations and support. Also, the definition of revolution could be debated of whether it literally means a radical movement towards change, or, in America's case, being the beginning of change in political, social, and economic structure.

3 comments:

  1. Grant,
    I completely agree with your claim. Both sides of the argument can be well supported and the answer will vary depending on the individuals perspective.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with most of what you said here; I agree that you could take this argument in many different directions, all with very different results. However, in your statement, you only look at the American Revolution through the eyes of other revolutions, comparing the two (or three). If you have a specific definition of what a social revolution is, why do you need to compare it to others at all? Why couldn't you just decide if it was a social revolution or not based on what is defined as a social revolution? This would give a more specific answer; although again, the definition of a social revolution could definitely vary from individual to individual.

    ReplyDelete